Open
Forum
New Delhi, 6 December 2021
Phasing Out Coal
DEVELOPMENT Vs
ENVIRONMENT
By Dhurjati Mukherjee
India’s defense of coal use has come in for
criticism at and since the COP26. In the debate over phasing out fossil fuels,
coal in particular, the moot question is that countries like India are in a
developing state and have, like it, a target of providing cheap electricity to
all villages and households. Is it prudent to sacrifice development needs for
those of the environment?
In the days since the summit’s end, India was
portrayed in the West as the principal villain responsible for weakening an
agreement aimed at saving the planet. For over seven decades,
India has championed not just its interests but those of the developing world
at international, but this time, it could possibly not be successful in
resisting pressure from the developed world. Island nations, specially in the
Caribbean and the Pacific, among the most vulnerable to climate change, are leading
demands for dramatic policy shifts and were understandably the angriest with
the summit text.
New Delhi, at the moment, is facing
accusations of having trampled over the future needs of poor nations through
the defense of coal use. India’s anonymous response so far is a version of ‘it
wasn’t just me. Others are responsible too”. That’s not how leaders behave.
They don’t pass the buck. They explain their actions clearly and transparently.
India and many other major developing economies have reasonable arguments why
it is harder – almost impossible --for them to commit in 2021 to a time-bound
phase out of coal.
In its report “India Energy Outlook 2021’, the International Energy Agency
(IEA) raised concern over uncertainties surrounding India’s coal industry, at a
time when shortage in supply of coal has resulted in the threat of large-scale
power shortages across the country. The energy sector has been impacted
by the pandemic, wherein the industry saw a 15 per cent drop in investment in
2020. Currently, India’s energy needs, which have doubled since 2000, are
largely being met by coal, oil, and biomass. Moreover, the country’s import
bill for coal is likely to triple in the coming two decades. It suggested
India, the third-largest consumer of energy in the world, to shift its energy
dependence to cleaner and renewable sources of energy.
India depends on fossil fuel for 70 per cent
of its electricity needs and China for over 50 per cent of its requirements.
As Union Minister for Environment, Forests and Climate Change Bhupender
Yadav had candidly explained at COP26, developed nations have used coal for
centuries before now shifting to slightly cleaner fossil fuels like gas. Asking
developing nations to meet the same timeline for ending coal use as their
wealthy counterparts is to condemn emerging economies to slow down development.
The implications of phasing out coal in a
steady manner, say over a 10-year period would entail not just huge financial
burden on the country but also lead to loss of jobs in the sector. Though an
increase in renewable capacity is very much necessary, starting the process of
phasing out coal at present is indeed an impossible task. It needs to be
stressed that the difference between the developed nations, which have abundant
financial resources and technological strength with those of Third World
countries like India has no justification whatsoever. Moreover, the scenario is
compounded by the fact that technology transfer as also financial grants in the
environment sector, as promised at the Paris meet, has not been met by the
West.
However, to start with the country should
concentrate on evolving technologies where emissions from coal can be kept at
the minimum. Experts are of the opinion that mining of low ash coal has to be
encouraged and more washeries with modern technology have to be set up as present
coal washing is not effective.
Another important development is the recent
prediction of Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways Nitin Gadkari that
cost of electric vehicles (EVs) will be the same as petrol and diesel cars, if
not less in the not-too-distant future. “India is waiting, as EV revolution
with 220 startups companies for engaging in innovation of EV technology is the
most cost-effective manner. Moreover, big auto manufacturers have also entered
the competition to reduce the cost of EV manufacture”, he added at the Annual General
Meeting of the Indian Chamber of Commerce. In fulfilling the country’s
commitment at COP26, Gadkari also said that EV trucks and EV tractors are being
introduced in the Indian roads shortly.
The minister also raised hopes by announcing
that 50 per cent ethanol production in aviation fuel is being contemplated.
Brazil has successfully done so. In this connection, Gadkari has taken the
right stand that since we produce so much rice that can feed the world, “we can
produce ethanol from rice waste”, thereby benefiting farmers and controlling
emissions.
The big challenge before India is that though
renewables, green hydrogen and even nuclear power may get fresh impetus,
whether it would be able to balance development with environmental concerns.
But at no cost can the development process be stalled, specially since this
directly benefits the lower segments of society. The developed world has
achieved all this and is both technologically and financially strong to make
the necessary shift.
But this is not the case with India. It goes
without saying that at present, phasing out coal may stand in the way of
various programmes, specially rural electrification throughout the country, as
power needs are destined to increase with development picking up. Physical
as also social infrastructure cannot develop fast without availability of
coal-based power.
Rightly, Prime Minister Modi has pointed to
the ‘colonial mindset’ of developed nations and that some in India too were
using Western benchmarks without examining the developmental issues. He observed:
“Today there are no colonies of any country in the world but the colonial
mindset has not ceased to exist. This mindset is giving birth to many skewed
ideas… The resources and the path which led to the Western countries reaching
the status of ‘developed’, today there is an attempt to restrict the same
resources and the same path for developing nations”.
Thus, there is an imperative need of
balancing urgent development needs with environmental concerns and, though the
undersigned is an environmental activist and researcher, development that
benefits the poorer sections of society has to be given top most priority, even
over any other concern as poverty and squalor still haunt the country. ---INFA
(Copyright, India
News & Feature Alliance)
|