Events
& Issues
New Delhi, 10 June 2021
SDGs &COVID-19
SHIFT FOCUS ON
INEQUITIES
By DrS.Saraswathi
(Former Director,
ICSSR, New Delhi)
Life goes on as usual, and it has to -
pandemic or lockdown -
and NITI Ayoghasreleasedits 2020 SDG (Sustainable Development Goals) Index.The
country’s over-all scorehas improved from 60 in 2019 to 66 in 2020. Kerala canboast of rankingfirst consistently
and Bihar maylament over its steady backwardness. Inter-State disparities
continueand are notupset by the impact of
Covid-19.
SDGs area collection of 17 global goals
designed to be a “blueprint to achieve a better and more sustainable future for all”.These were conceived
post-MDG (2015) by consensus among renowned experts from the UN, NGOs, and private
sectors, with a team of economists to prepare
research papers to arrive at most effective targets for post-2015 development
agenda within certain core issues like food security,gender equality, health,
infectious diseases, nutrition, population and demography, air pollution,
governance and institutions, poverty, water
and sanitation,etc., totaling 22.
Setting targets and goals and making declarations have been a strategy of the
United Nations and its agencies to go forward and makeprogress though
targeted approach isnotalways
successful.
NITIAayog launched this index in 2018to
monitor the country’s progress towards the goals set in 2015 for 2030 on data-based assessment. It
isintended to take stock of the situation and progress and also to stimulate healthy
competition between States and UTs in the race to reach the Goals. It
ranksStates and UTs by compiling a complex index on SDGs.Ranking of States on
performance inthesocial sector including health and education initiated by the
NITIAayog can promote healthy competition. The Centre, as the national head,
does not link financing and performance
as States face different kinds of problemsdue to a variety of reasons affecting performance.
In competitive federalism in India, policy-making
is not a one-way route. A system of Centre-State participation in policy
formulation has been evolved consistent with the constitutional scheme of
distribution of powers between the Union and States. The shareof fiscal
resources for the States is transferred to respective States and governments
have autonomy to fix their priorities.States neednot look to the Centre for
policy guidance as a routine.However,States
have to adhere to national objectives. The arrangementfacilitates both
autonomy and equality.
Kerala’s score on SDG Index 2020 has improved
from 70 in 2019 to 75 in 2020. Tamil Nadu and Himachal Pradesh are close
followers with a score of 74. At the bottom are Bihar, Jharkhand, and Assam scoring 52, 56, and 57
respectively. The over-allindex score is given on the basis of total performanceand
States are classified in four groups -- aspirant
0-49; performer 50-64; front-runner 65-99; and achiever 100.All Stateshave
shown improvement compared to previous year.Haryana and Mizoram show the biggest
gain.No Stateremains merely as aspirant, nor anyone has become anachiever.
An assessment by the UN in March of the
impact ofCovid-19 on the SDGs found that rising inequality due to pandemic will
be a common feature in the region. However,theIndex shows no alarming growth in gaps between
performers.This year’sindexgives greater weight to social inequality instead of
economic assessedin the two previous years.
Covid-19negativity, it is notedin studies,
affected several goals of SDG like removal of poverty (Goal 1), eradication of hunger
(Goal2), good health and well-being (Goal 3), decent economic growth (Goal 8),
and reduced inequality (Goal 8).Under the combined impact of Covid-19 and theinescapable lockdown in various degrees,
economic and social living are under tremendous pressure pulling the nation
away from SDG Goals. Still, our performanceisfairly good.
The path for SDGs was laid by Millennium
Development Goals (MDG) 2000-2015. The focus then was on over-all progress
ignoring inequities within countries. It is considered necessary now to
disaggregate data and results by States and by significant categories like
gender, economic status, geographic
area, etc., so as to understand the true status of progress and identify areas
requiring special attention.
Inequality in various forms is recognised as
aprincipal issue that is undermining over-all
development in ourtime.Reducing inequalities has become a big challengein
global policy-making. There is consensus in theory that all should enjoy equal
access to equal opportunity. The Report
on UN2030 and Beyond says that, “Leave no one behind” serves as the theme of 2030 agenda for sustainable development. But, application
ofthe concept inpractice is a challenge in many countries,including India.
Sectoral, gender, economic and other disparities intervene and work in both ways to aggravate
or lessen the inequalities.
NITI Aayog’s 2020 Index has changed the
indicators for assessing inequality omitting economic indicators like rate of
household expenditure and adding instead social indicators like SC, ST and women representation in elected
legislatures and panchayatsand crimes against SC and ST.
Economic inequality indicated by industry
andinfrastructure development suffered heavily
decliningby 10 points. Decent
work lost 3 points. Covid-19
andlockdown have made a big dent in individual and national economy. The poorer
sections suffer more. However,poverty and removal of hunger saw
significantimprovement.
The goal of Health and Well-being is bound to move further away since
healthcare is very expensive and beyond affordability of most people in India.
While MDG had three health goals, SDG set one only to “ensure healthy lives and
promote well-being for all in all ages” and to tackle the epidemic of
non-communicable diseases, substance abuse, and ill-effects of environmentalhazards.It hasbeen assumed that
health involves a broad range of social determinants covered by other SDGs in13targets.
Health service concentrating on fighting
Covid-19, other programmes are bound to suffer. Healthis related to other goals
like poverty eradication, gender equality, education, food security, water and
sanitation, etc.Health is actually brought at the centre of thedevelopment
agenda longbefore coronavirus struck the world. The pandemic has shown us that
sustainability is something that shouldbe taken more seriously by governments.
Universal health coverage is a targetin the Health Goal.
Public health cannot be maintained without removing
inequitiesin other spheres. Epidemic and
pandemiccontrol,unlike non-communicable diseases, is impossible without
reaching health services to everybody.
Unequal services and unequal utilisation ofservices (by ignorance, intent, design, or sabotage) will undermine
efforts at fighting the pandemic. No one should be left behind.
Will the country succeed in shifting focus to
inequities, vulnerabilities, and rivalries besides wants and shortages so as to provide
healthcare, and minimum amenities to all? Will India handle problems like
migrantlabour from rural areas, and unorganised workforce in urban areas, who need and deserve support to get over
inequalities? Will the government crush anti-national forces that undermine efforts at fighting the
pandemic by false propagandaand black-marketing in health goods and aggravating
social differences? At the base of all ills is rampant inequalities of various
kinds. ---INFA
(Copyright, India
News & Feature Alliance)
|