Economic Highlights
New Delhi, 22 February 2021
PSBs
Disinvestment
PRIVATISATION
NOT MANTRA
By
Shivaji Sarkar
The country is in a quandary
about the privatisation of the public sector banks and needs to reconsider. Amendments
to the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) 1970 and
1980 are on the cards. The two laws led to bank nationalisation of the banks in
two phases.
Finance Minister Nirmala
Sitharaman has announced privatisation of PSBs as part of disinvestment drive
to garner Rs 1.75 lakh crore, in reality not a very large sum. That has raised
another question whether for such small gains, the nation should sell the
family silver. Or why should it go back to 1969 when these were taken over? The
banks were in the hands of large houses. They have been defying regulations and
many unsavoury practices were in use, including taking out funds risking the
banks and quietly refunding causing immense interest and operation cost losses.
This apart, the small lenders had little space in the controlled practices.
Some banks were off and on were in the news of facing liquidation thought the
1960s.
The takeover was then
considered a bold step as now the announcement of selling off is being
projected as a bold decision. The Narendra Modi government is in a financial
crisis and wants the nation to steer out of it. All of it though is not the
doing of this government. The bank crisis has built up with the changes in Basel
recapitalisation norms as well as the growing NPAs.
As of March 31, 2010, gross
PSB NPAs were Rs 8.06 lakh crore. A 2020 JC Review study by four academicians --
Sunita Sharma, Rajesh Kothari, DS Rathore and Jagdish Prasad -- say that the private sector banks were not
doing well post 2012 (as also were many public sector banks) and the NPAs have
been growing. They say that the economic performance had not declined 2012-2019
but sharp rise in NPAs raise questions on transparency in showing correct
picture of their health. The banks, they note had been concealing facts
particularly about high value accounts, which in their opinion, had come under
NPA even before 2010-13. “Increasing NPAs suggest that high number of credit
defaults affect profitability, liquidity and solvency positions of (all) banks”,
they say.
They found Axis Bank
profitability since 2017 has continuously been falling due to rise in NPAs till
partly checked in 2019. Similarly, the ICICI bank NPAs continuously increased since
2015 and reached a peak of 8.85 per cent in 2018. Though in 2019 it reduced to
6.7 per cent but the net profit further came down due to higher provisioning.
Banks in general have
witnessed a decline in the profitability during the last about eight years.
That raises a question whether the PSBs should be singled out in a choppy
market particularly when some private sector banks indulged in major
malpractices. Does it mean that privatisation is not a panacea? This is a
critical question that the government and the society need to have a review.
The privatisation cannot be a mantra. It seems the problems lie in
practices and those in the country need severe corrections.
The study is almost in tune
with the 2018 report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance where
it observed that the capacity to lend has been severely affected due to NPAs.
It says, “A lot
of the loans currently classified as NPAs originated in mid-2000s, at a time
when the economy was booming and business outlook was very positive. Large
corporations were granted loans for projects based on extrapolation of their
recent growth and performance. With loans being available more easily than
before, corporations grew highly leveraged, implying that most financing was
through external borrowings rather than internal promoter equity. But as economic
growth stagnated following the global financial crisis of 2008, the repayment
capability of these corporations decreased. This contributed to what is now
known as India’s Twin Balance Sheet problem, where both the banking sector
(that gives loans) and the corporate sector (that takes and has to repay these
loans) have come under financial stress”.
So the prescription of
privatising the PSBs needs a review and a new approach to curing the disease
than shifting it from one clinic to another. Poor regulatory frameworks and
related problems are some of the pitfalls. Additionally profit-centric and
shareholder wealth maximising monopolies by banks will not to cater to the
needy individuals.
The government would also be
losing out on potential dividends that give significant budgetary support. In
2014, Rs 88, 188 crore were paid by PSES, including Rs 43996 crore from PSBs.
Since, however, the PSB dividend contribution has been dwindling though RBI has
paid about Rs 2 lakh crore during the past two years.
A problem the government
faces is of continuous recapitalisation – pumping in funds as per Basel norms. During
financial year (FY) 2015 to FY2019 the government infused Rs 2.5 lakh crore
plus Rs 70,000 crore in FY2021 and Rs 25,000 crore in FY2022 – Rs 3.5 lakh
crore. This is natural if the profitability of banks comes down. But so it has
happened to private banks as well. It means there is a basic flaw in the banking
operations. The PSB losses mounted to Rs 85,000 in FY 2018 crore and came down
to Rs 50,000 crore in 2019.
Suggesting a solution is not
easy. The deposits with PSBs are rising. In 2018 it was Rs 117 lakh crore and
in FY2018, it rose to Rs 128 lakh crore. Savings bank deposits also rose by Rs
4 lakh crore between FY 2018 and FY 2019 from Rs 35.9 lakh crore to Rs 39.1
lakh crore.
But liabilities are rising
due to defaults, increase in operational costs of larger low-quality accounts
like Jandhan, digital and other populist operations. The recapitalisation
despite a high for the government has been below the operational needs as the
banks were to support announcements like farm loans, MUDRA and other schemes.
The faults are for
extra-banking causes. Privatisation is not likely to solve these but even in
their dwindling health, the PSBs have enormous wealth and before these are sold
to a select group of eager large corporate buyers, the country needs to wait
and reconsider massive revamping of the system and through that how to
strengthen the economy. Once the silver is lost, it could again be reinventing
the wheel.---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)
|