Open Forum
New Delhi, 20
December 2020
Spectre of Reforms
GOVT MUST BE
REALISTIC
By Dhurjati Mukherjee
There is much debate
over NDA government having initiated major reforms which would change the face
of the economy with high growth rates projected. However, while claims are
being made, there is virtually no in-depth clear picture whether these reforms
have actually changed the lives of the toiling masses across the country.
Addressing ASSOCHAM’s
Foundation week ceremony recently, Prime Minister Modi cited the reforms undertaken
these past six years and the impact these had in the country, wherein the proposition
has changed from ‘why India’ to ‘why not India’! “The world trusts Indian
economy. Record FDI and FPI during the pandemic is a testimony to this”, he observed
adding that 1500 archaic and obsolete laws had been done away with and new
framed to keep pace with the changing investment order. This, he said was just
one example of the government’s outlook. However, the impression among a
certain section of society is that these reforms have largely benefitted the big
business houses, the rich and to a certain extent, the upper middle income
sections.
An important emphasis
laid by Modi related to partnerships with State governments, farm organisations,
and industry associations for better infrastructure and better markets. “If our
farm sector gets proper infrastructure, gets better markets, then the entire
rural economy can scale up new heights”, the Prime Minister stated. But who
would undertake this? In the midst of the farmers’ agitation, the Government is
unwilling to listen, and is accused of aiding the big corporate. However, Modi urged
the industry too to go all out to make India self-reliant and said investment
in research and development must be stepped up.
While the points made
sound very pertinent, in reality these are not being implemented. For example,
the conditions of small and marginal farmers have not improved during the past
six years and partnerships with farmers’ organisations are virtually absent.
Moreover, the federal spirit is missing and this has been alleged by many State
organisations. Thus, the bonding claimed by Modi with peoples’ organizations is
difficult to accept.
Insofar with regard
to closeness of the government with business groups and industry associations
is obviously accepted because its focus is helping industry in all possible
ways. But available data reveals that the investment of industry in R&D is
very meager compared to most emerging economies. Thus to accept that the
private sector would steer innovation and bring about technological changes is
nothing but wishful thinking.
If reforms had any
effect, this was not manifest during the pandemic and the country is witness to
the sufferings of migrant workers and labour for over six months or so.
Moreover, delving into the job scenario, it has been found that compared to 6.1
per cent unemployment rate among youth (aged 15 to 29) in 2012, this has increased
to over 20 per cent during 2019, as per a recent paper of labour economist
Prof. Santosh Mehrotra. A guess that the rate must have increased to around 25
per cent in the past year, that is 2020, would not be wrong.
Also India’s ranking
would not have slipped to 131 out of 189 countries in the UNDP’s Human Development Index (HDI) for
2019, down one step from rank 130 in the previous year. Even Bhutan ranked 134th
last year and leapfrogged India to the 129th spot. The report found
that India’s gross national income per capita had fallen to $6681 (Rs 4.9
lakh) in 2019 from $ 6829 (Rs 5.03 lakh) in 2018 on the basis of purchasing
power parity. According to an expert of the Centre for the Study of Regional
Development of JNU, “the slide in global ranking is proof that private
investment is unlikely to deliver gains in the social sector”.
In fact, after two
decades of progress, the number of people affected by hunger has been
increasing since the low of 628 million in 2014. In 2019, the number was 688
million, up 60 million in only five years, the UNDP report
stated. Estimates for 2020, including the effect of Covid -19 pandemic,
range from 780 million people affected by hunger to 829 million. All this again
proves that so-called reforms have had no effect on the socio-economic
situation.
The present scenario
may be encouraging for the industrial sector with improvements quite fast and
deceleration expected to be much less to around 7.3 per cent in the current
fiscal, as recently predicted by NCAER. But the conditions of the economically
weaker sections and the poor are indeed critical and there is no effort by the
government to redress their suffering. Though we hear of various welfare
schemes, announced with much fanfare, the question is whether these are
reaching the real beneficiaries at the grass-root levels, specially in backward
regions?
The advance of
technology has benefitted the upper echelons of society but not the rural
population, most of whom have to struggle for an existence. One may mention
here that the Indian Council for Agricultural Technology (ICAR) has lavish
guest houses in many cities but does not have the requisite infrastructure to
help and advice small farmers in sub-divisions and blocks of the country. It
can very well be affirmed that technology has mostly served the interests of
the upper echelons of society and negligible benefit has accrued to the
struggling masses.
The whole question
before the country in the New Year is what the government has been aiming at
and how, with its avowed policy of raising GDP growth, the living standards of
the poor and the backward sections would be improved. There is no perspective
plan of the government in this regard of say how to increase employment
generation, what sectors need to be encouraged to achieve this, how to help
small and marginal farmers, how to ensure employment to migrant workers who are
still without work, how small traders could increase their income etc.
Another important but
neglected area is the effect of natural disasters on the rural population,
specially the impoverished sections. While, on the one hand, India’s
air pollution deaths are about 30 per cent higher than earlier estimates – 1.67
million premature deaths during 2019 or more than ten times the country’s
corona virus death toll during 2020, on the other, the casualties due to floods
and cyclones have been increasing every year. Even in 2020, floods and cyclones
in the country have played havoc with lakhs of people expected to be affected.
Reforms, whether in
agriculture, labour or infrastructure sector, are definitely needed but these
would have to be formulated keeping the above sections in mind and how their
livelihood conditions can be improved. A cadre based party like the BJP should
change its strategy and evolve a plan for the next five to 10 years whereby
there is an all-round thrust on employment generation, rural rejuvenation,
increased agri production benefitting small and marginal farmers, development
if entrepreneurship etc. Only better reasoning and a pro-poor approach, geared
towards welfare of the masses, can witness success of such a plan in the coming
months.---INFA
(Copyright, India
News & Feature Alliance)
|