Political
Diary
New Delhi, 8 September
2020
Ladakh On A Hair
Trigger
WHO WILL COME UP
TRUMPS?
By Poonam I Kaushish
Neighbour or enemy?
Both. Indeed, India-China relations are like being on a roller coaster,
depending on which way the political wind is blowing, north or South.
Presently, it’s bellicose, defiant and
eyeball confrontationist with both New Delhi and Beijing standing there ground:
Don’t mess with us.
Yet,
it takes two to tango! Recall, till yesterday New Delhi had bought Beijing’s
line that the border issue could be compartmentalized, while they pursued other
aspects of bilateral ties. But, Galwan and fresh claims in Eastern Ladakh have
given a lie to China’s proposition. Whereby, New Delhi is resetting its China
policy by making clear it is no patsy and when push comes to shove it will
retaliate.
As
the Army’s preemptive action 29-30 August to strengthen our position and
prevent China from unilaterally changing the status quo on the Pangong Tso
southern bank shows India can no longer be arm-twisted, as in 1962. Notwithstanding,
Beijing’s angry response which have heightened tensions on the Line of Actual
Control (LAC) in Ladakh with neither knowing where it is, as both countries
have differing border perception.
Towards
that end, it has signalled two changes in the way it deals with Beijing on the
border issue. One, security forces are responding with alacrity to attempts by
China to change the situation on the ground. Asserted Chief of Defence Staff
Gen Rawat, “Delhi has military options”. A far cry from the disengagement and
de-escalation that military commanders continue to discuss.
Two,
diplomatically, the multiple rounds of talks between military commanders and
National Security Advisor Dulat seem to have made little headway. While India
wants China to revert to status quo ante which goes unheeded, Beijing wants New
Delhi to isolate the border issue from the broader bilateral ties, which has
been vociferously turned down.
Questionably,
can India defuse this impasse akin
to a time bomb? Even as it musters world leaders’ support can New Delhi diplomatically
counter Beijing’s drive for supremacy in the region? What options does it have? Does
its foreign policy assertive trends portend the likelihood of an aggressive
outcome?
A
shadow of uncertainty hangs as the border remains on a hair trigger. New Delhi
needs diplomatic, economic and military deterrents in place to counter
Beijing’s moves. Deal with a boundary that remains un-demarcated, undelineated
and disputed over seven decades with a neighbour who periodically flexes
muscle.
Remember,
it suits China to have an unresolved boundary which allows it to make fresh
claims and unilaterally push the LAC westward as a means of pressuring India.
Think. It has refused to disengage at Pangong Tso, Gogra and Despang despite
talks and wants to continue pushing the envelope to break India’s back.
Further,
Beijing is no longer interested in maintaining peace and tranquility at
borders, instead Xi Jinping wants to impose a fait accompli on its neighbours
by independently changing facts and can happily go to war or escalate border
tension because aggression and violence is its go-to strategy to resolve issues.
Moreover, it is adamant to superimpose its position on a contested LAC aiming
to capture as much land as possible before things settle down.
Today,
Beijing is a totally different beast and we have hardly been able to understand
it, let alone manage to tame and befriend it on our terms. Its preferred model
is subjugation through tyrannical power designed to humiliate, stifle and
weaken the other side. In fact, this is the common thread between aggressive
Chinese military manoeuvres in the South and East China Seas and Ladakh where
intrusions of territory are viewed as over-riding international agreements and
rules.
From
Tiananmen Square to Hong Kong protests, from sinking Vietnamese shipping boats
to ambushing Indian troops with nailed rods, China can go to any level to get
what it wants. Last time we trusted them, it was the infamous 1962 war, and
India cannot forget it. This is the country we are dealing with.
Besides,
China is busy raising its profile in the sub-Continent by participating in a quadrangular
meet with Afghanistan, Nepal and Pakistan, building the China-Pakistan Economic
Corridor connecting China's largest province Xinjiang with Pakistan's Gwadar
port in Balochistan, passing through POK which violates India's territorial
integrity. It is growing footprints in Nepal by bolstering infrastructure close
to the Lipulekh pass and the newly disputed areas near Kalapani which are altering
the security dynamic for India.
The
Chinese are also offering massive financial assistance to several infrastructure
projects in Dhaka and Sylhet and 97% duty-free access for Bangladeshi goods,
becoming its largest trading partner and investor. It has upgraded its defence
relationship by constructing a modern submarine base in Cox's Bazaar, a new
naval base in Pathuakali, and ensuring delivery of a Chinese Corvette to
strengthen Bangladesh’s naval forces.
To counter China’s ‘string of pearls’
strategy, India’s Look-Act
East Policy is forging alliances with Beijing’s neighbours. It is engaging with
Myanmar, Sri Lanka and Vietnam etc. It is also reviewing
its policy on Tibet, Xinjiang and Hong Kong and gradually upgrade and strength
it ties with Taiwan.
Certainly,
one has no illusions about Sino-Indian complex ties but given China’s hegemonic
ambitions of exacerbating border tensions, a shadow of uncertainty hangs. With
both countries flexing their muscle the danger of military escalation along the
LAC has increased. Diminishing that risk in the short term should be a
priority.
Consequently,
our relations with China will remain a serious problem, requiring engagement
and hedging. Already New Delhi is economically pulling out all the stops to hit
Beijing financially. It has banned over 224 Chinese apps and stalled financial
investments in Indian companies. Prime Minister Modi is pushing hard to
showcase India as an alternate destination for global value chains.
However,
there is awareness of the need for continued Chinese investment flows and the
importance of not getting into a hostile fracas with a stronger neighbour.
Hence, tensions between these competing and contradictory imperatives would
need to be managed as the stakes for the neighbours are higher and more complex
now.
Thus,
unless there is a comprehensive breakthrough, Indian and Chinese soldiers are destined,
for now, to try and stare each other out at the LAC. Having been used to
browbeat the Indian army in the past, the PLA is perhaps surprised that India
2020 is a far cry from India 1962 by its swift counter build-up and firmness.
We need to expand these capabilities further.
Modi
realizes that in today’s geo-strategic political reality pragmatism dictate
real politic. New Delhi’s new assertiveness would need all the wisdom, maturity
and restraint to ensure that it remains in control of the Indo-China script. In
the long-term India-China relations will be determined by India’s strategic
goals and objectives vis-à-vis the
evolving regional and global security environment.
India needs to navigate these turbulent waters
with measured and calibrated response. Ladakh underscores Beijing’s seriousness
about demarcating the Indo-Chinese border but wants to keep the situation
ambiguous to enable its salami slicing tactics to incrementally grab territory.
Even as its
neighbor wants to create a ‘new normal’, tough responses to provocations and
clear red zones are the best guarantee of peace in the sub-Continent.
Today, a chill has
set in Indo-China ties. Deep mistrust and lack of confidence is apparent. New
Delhi needs to walk a diplomatic tightrope, make some hard choices and pick up
the gauntlet. Yet the two have not
rejected dialogue, even when it is no more than a repetition of known
positions. India needs to balance the scales and
defeat the Chinese bully at its own game by creating appropriate defence. It
needs to stay aggressive. It's only when there is fear of retaliation that
China will stop taking us for granted. ‘Enough’. ----- INFA
Copyright, India News and Feature Alliance)
|