Open Forum
New Delhi, 17 June
2020
Ingrained Inefficiency
CHANGE IN OUTLOOK VITAL
By Dhurjati Mukherjee
Prospects of foreign
companies changing locations from China to other countries such as India,
Malaysia, Vietnam, Thailand etc are said to being contemplated. While many
believe India could be a big beneficiary, it suffers a drawback as experts
opine that most foreign companies have little interest to relocate here given
factors such as inefficiency, corruption and lack of infrastructure.
Inefficiency is unfortunately
ingrained in our system. Some of this may be attributed to manual functions,
instead of automation while others may be due to lack of clear-cut methodology
and planning. Be it in power transmission or completion of infrastructure
projects, inefficiency results in delays and add to project costs. Even in vital
areas like water usage or fruit preservation there is 30 to 40% wastage and the
lack of warehousing has led to farmers throwing their produce on the streets.
The recent rhetoric
of ‘atmanirbhar Bharat’
(self-reliance), has little basis for a country importing basic products. India
has become an assembly hub for mobile phones, lighting and consumer electronics
and its domestic value addition is under 30%. In Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Taiwan, the
Philippines, South Korea and China, while manufacturing has contributed 30-50%
of the GDP, the Indian manufacturing sector’s contribution has moved from just 16%
to 18.32% in the past 10 years.
Though huge amount of
resources being utilised to improve efficiency of processes and institutions
may have had some positive indicators in recent years, the system has a long
way to go. While automation and digitisation have helped in gearing up some efficiency
in industrial processes, foreign made scientific machines are largely preferred
to indigenous ones. Equipments manufactured in China, and even South Korea,
have been flooding the global market, including India’s. However, it’s difficult
to understand why developed nations, which have high labour costs, are
successful in selling these at competitive prices in our country. Perhaps, their
technology and expertise is of a higher order.
Nevertheless, there are
business houses which have shown high degrees of efficiency such as Reliance
group, the Tata group, Mahindra & Mahindra, Bharati Airtel etc. At the same
time, monopolies are created due to disadvantages which include technology,
performance standardisation etc.
Insofar as
infrastructure is concerned, while the British need to be given credit for building
the Railways, bridges, tunnels etc, the maintenance over the years has been
poor and we have had to consult foreign firms for reconstruction or for that
matter take Japanese technological aid to build the metro railways. In the
financial sector there are umpteen examples of inefficiency. If we look at public
sector banks, their performance and functioning leaves much to be desired. The rise
in NPAs and poor levels of profitability compared to private sector reveals
sheer mismanagement and lop-sided policies. And there is lack of transparency
and autonomy in our institutions.
An example may well
be of a recent report regarding the waters of the holy Ganga river at Rishikesh
and Haridwar. These have now been classified as ‘fit for drinking after
chlorination’, as there has been a 54% reduction in faecal coliform (human
excreta) and 20% reduction in biochemical oxygen demand – a parameter to assess
the quality of effluent or wastewater. It appears the government has been
wasting crores of rupees on projects when effective action of controlling
hydropower plants, mining activities and industrial waste has not been taken for
years due to sheer negligence and inefficiency. Either industrial units
continue to dump waste in the river by bribing officials or the State
government has taken a lackadaisical approach and wasted the huge Ganga Action
Plan money.
Over efficiency, feel
some experts may have a side effect-- reduce number of jobs and create
unemployment. But it hasn’t really been the case. Modernisation along with
diversification and value addition does help in increasing employment and this
has been demonstrated, not just by China but other countries including South
Korea, Vietnam.
Gearing up of indigenous
manufacturing is intrinsically linked to efficiency and standardisation. If
India has to become globally competitive in the manufacturing sector, there needs
to be skill upgradation along with use of long lasting right materials. Also
prices need to be competitive to allure nations to buy Indian products.
In the case of
agriculture, which engages over 50% of workforce but contributes only 14% to
GDP 14%, efficiency and raise in income of farmers would only be achieved through
increase in productivity, diversification of crops and government initiatives.
Small farm owners could come together and share technology for better and
viable produce. Another aspect is lack of warehousing to stock foodgrains. This
has allowed traders to manipulate prices with the farmers, whose staple crops,
vegetables and fruits would rot without stocking facility. In the backdrop of
starvation deaths in the country, this is ironical.
India’s quest to
become an emerging power cannot become a reality unless the whole system comes
out of the bania mentality and
becomes truly westernised as regards governance and efficiency is concerned.
Unless there is good governance situation may not improve in this country.
However, for this we
need to raise the efficiency bar as well as ensure autonomy in government
institutions. The political leaders and bureaucrats will need to change outlook
and overhaul the entire spectrum of governance. High levels of efficiency and
skill in all sectors of the economy that China has been successful in
implementing has to become a reality. This is manifest from the fact how
efficiency and promptness has enabled the UK to begin human trials for Covid-19
vaccine. As pointed out, a modern system has to be decentralised, both
political and economic, and greater importance given to grass-root organisations
to ensure vibrancy and better health.
To become a major
power, transformation is much desired –efficient, forward looking and more so
when growth is predicted to be negative in the current fiscal. Without
innovation and efficiency the self-reliance or manufacturing boost cannot become
a reality. Also the level of corruption needs to be checked at all levels but
mostly at the top. Better performance, resource saving, dedication and
sincerity is what the nation needs. ---INFA
(Copyright,
India News & Feature Alliance)
|