Events
& Issues
New Delhi, 7 May 2020
Shramik Specials
NOT PERMANENT ARRANGEMENT
By Dr S. Saraswathi
(Former Director, ICSSR, New Delhi)
The Indian Railways
started “Shramik Special” trains to take back to their home States migrant
workers, tourists, pilgrims, students and others who were stranded due to
nationwide lockdown for more than a month. The decision taken on the eve of
third extension of lockdown from 4 to 17 May is a great relief particularly to
migrant workers who have no work and depend on government support for food and
shelter. Census of 2011 enumerated 4 crore population as migrant labourers.
A status report filed
by the Ministry of Home Affairs in the Supreme Court showed that a total of
22,567 shelters by State governments and 3,909 by NGOs were working in the
country. The Government of Kerala, foremost in this regard, is running over 65
% of active shelters and relief camps numbering 15,541 for stranded migrant
workers. Apart from these, employers and industries are providing food and
shelter to about 15 lakh such workers in the country. Food is being provided to
over 54 lakh people by Union and State governments and to about 30 lakh by NGOs.
Five Shramik Special trains
were scheduled to run in the first batch from Nasik in Maharashtra to Lucknow in
UP, and to Bhopal in MP, from Aluva in Kerala to Bhubaneshwar in Odisha, from Jaipur
in Rajasthan to Patna in Bihar, and from Kota in Rajasthan to Hatia in
Jharkhand. One such special train left Lingampally in
Telangana to Hatia in Jharkhand on 1 April even before guidelines were released
by the Ministry of Home Affairs. Several such trains are expected to follow.
The migrants will be quarantined for 21 days.
The trains will carry
only passengers registered with the concerned State Governments and no other
passengers. The arrangement is partly in response to massive protests of
migrants particularly in Delhi and Maharashtra and their desperate move in many
States to somehow reach their native places totally violating all lockdown
norms. In any case, Union Government seems to be proceeding methodically in
dealing with social problems arising from the outbreak of epidemic. There is no
quick solution when the country is fighting multiple problems.
Shramik Special is no
easy run. While many States are demanding special trains to transport migrant
workers, Bihar Government is reported to have denied permission for arrival of
the trains. Protests have erupted in
Chennai by “guest” workers, not provided transport in the first batch to return
to their home States.
Tamil Nadu Government
has identified 4.82 lakh guest workers of whom 3.2 lakh are in 4,228
accommodation centres and government shelters. But, there is no State-wise
statistics or any information on the number wanting to go back or stay where
they are. Situation is similar in all States while workers, restless and
clueless about their future, become angry and unruly. In Kerala, it is claimed
that there are 3.6 lakh guest workers from Assam, Bihar, Odisha, UP, and West
Bengal staying in 20,826 camps spread across the State – all of them wanting to
go back.
Demands from State
governments are of two types. Some want to send guest workers from other States
back to their homes; some like Chhattisgarh want Central government to make
arrangement to bring back their workers stranded in other States.
Running special
trains does not end the problem arising from migrant workers. The evacuation
exercise has to be carried on amidst chaotic conditions marked by protests of frustrated
workers, and circulation of fake news and rumours creating panic. Clashes
between migrants and the police are common as the situation itself is so
uncommon. Providing food and shelter and other essential amenities to thousands
of workers is a stupendous job unrelated to fighting the pandemic, and the task
involves the risk of escalation of the disease.
The tragedy in the
situation is that the prime concern of many political and other groups, which contribute
practically nothing for controlling the epidemic, is to magnify the migrant
problem. The situation continues to be explosive and has become the chief
culprit in breakdown of lockdown rules and complete disregard for social
distancing. It brought the migrants to the central point in the fight against
COVID-19 pandemic. A medical mission is obstructed by a non-medical factor and
has proved the immense importance of the social context and the readiness of
political interests to make best use of social problems. Migrant labour is
common in many countries, but internally it does not create a separate problem
as in India.
PILs seeking Supreme
Court direction to the Union government and concerned State governments to pay
basic minimum wages to migrant workers and to self-employed workers like rikshaw pullers during the lockdown
period have been rejected. The court declined to interfere with financial
allocations of the governments.
The issue of migrant
labour has become an extremely crucial issue for political parties to position
themselves in people’s mind. The Congress Working Committee adopted a
Resolution on 25 April (Thursday) drew the attention of the Central government
to the necessity of framing a policy under which migrant workers could return
to their homes if they wished and should be provided with health, safety
conditions, food and adequate money till then, be allowed to return to their
work after lockdown, and given compensation for loss incurred during the crisis
period.
The Indian
Constitution gives all citizens freedom to move to any State and has no system
of State citizenship. It goes without saying that migrant workers may return to
their work if their former employers agree. The arrangement is between the
employers and workers and no government is bound to take care of their travel
to the workplace after lockdown. Present situation is a national health emergency
requiring humanitarian relief and rescue work and once the pandemic subsides,
there is no crisis.
It is time to open
our eyes to the status of migrant labour – most of them living under the mercy
of contractors and placement agencies. Both agriculture and industry depend heavily
on migrant labour for efficiency and economy. Many of these workers, who are
employed as daily wage workers, are far away from their homes -- an unpleasant
working condition that hitherto has not bothered anybody.
Hence, in the place
of purely humanitarian considerations, a rights approach must be framed based
on due recognition of the importance of the growing sector of migrant labour in
our economy and granting certain rights and security to them.
The plight of migrant
labourer, considered as a social issue, raises questions over the relative
responsibility of State and Central governments or of the “host” or “guest” State
or that of the employers and workers. But, this is not the time to assume
positions on rights and responsibilities and play irresponsible politics. Questions
of responsibility will remain to be tackled after the present crisis.
Migrant labour, an
important component of labour market in India, has given rise to a huge
humanitarian problem. The economic consequences of the exodus of these workers
will have to be faced after the epidemic crisis. How many of them will be
willing to return to their work is a big question. Shramik Specials cannot become
permanent. ---INFA
(Copyright, India
News & Feature Alliance)
New Delhi
5 May 2020
|