EVENTS & ISSUES
New Delhi, 26 November 2007
Factionalism in BJP
IS MODI INDIA’S FUTURE?
By M D Nalapat
(Holds UNESCO Peace
Chair, Prof, Geopolitics, Manipal
Academy of
Higher Education, Ex-Resident Editor, Times of India, Delhi)
Indians seems to be unusually curious about their leaders.
How many of us know that Sonia Gandhi has two sisters, and that the three
completed secondary school in Italy
before finding work? How many are aware of the domestic arrangements in the
life of Atal Behari Vajpayee? Almost none. And a similar ignorance is
manifested about an individual who, if he wins once again in Gujarat,
could emerge as the main challenger to Sonia Gandhi's ascendancy in 2009,
Narendra Modi.
Rather than the 16 per cent growth rate of his State, the
Gujarat Chief Minister is defined in the media by the post-Godhra riots, the
rest of his record being ignored as completely as those who were torched to
death on the Godhra train. The act of
violence that sparked an inexcusable pogrom against innocents from the next
morning. Interestingly, most of those directly involved in the violence are now
on the anti-Modi side, being backed by a Congress Party which is aware of the
danger its minority votebank faces from a Modi victory next month
The riots themselves followed a three-stage pattern, and
sadly, this pattern has gone unnoticed by the media. The first stage was a
frenzied public reaction to the torching of the train compartment that
manifested itself in the form of attacks on members of the minority community.
After two days, the victims organized themselves and began to retaliate, so
that in this round, it was mostly members of the majority community that lost
their lives.
The next and final stage of the post-Godhra riots was the
most vicious, and according to some accounts, the funding for the
well-orchestrated killing during this round came from members of a (majority
community) mafia that wanted to break the monopoly that another mafia ( which
was populated by members of the minority) had over the illicit liquor trade in
Gujarat.
As in the ill-advised attempts to bring back Prohibition
into Haryana, the banning of alcohol in Gujarat
has not stopped the consumption as much as it has spawned the growth of a
vicious mafia to run the trade, which nets an estimated profit of Rs 3200
crores in unaccounted money.
Almost all the deaths during this “majority” mafia-funded
phase of the Gujarat killings were caused to
the minority community. And by the conclusion of the carnage, the
"minority" mafia had been driven out of the liquor trade in favour of
the "majority" mafia. This battle for spoils was behind the third and most brutal phase of the killings.
Clearly, it is a matter of shame that the Central and State Governments
were unable to prevent either this or the second and third stages of the
post-Godhra murders from getting played out. Prompt action would have saved 90
per cent of the lives lost in the Gujarat orgy that has blackened the face of India.
But equally with Narendra Modi, the then Central Government
headed by Atal Behari Vajpayee needs to be faulted for its failure to prevent
the killings of hundreds of innocent citizens, most of them members of the
minority community.
Moreover, exactly as the 1992 Ayodhya incident had shadowed
the Congress Party, the post-Godhra killings since 2002 have significantly
affected the BJP's ability to bring together a coalition of parties under its
leadership. The TDP and the AIADMK being just two examples of major political
parties unwilling to risk their minority votebanks by aligning with the Saffron
Party.
True, Modi has become anathema to liberal and secular India, but what
has yet to be attempted is a full examination of his life. Who, for example, is
aware that the teenager Modi spent nearly two years of his life at the
foothills of the Himalayas, seeking wisdom? Or,
as acquaintances say, that he was married off against his will at the age of 14
by his father to a girl two years younger, whom he never saw subsequently?
Because of the age factor, this wedding was not legal, and the young girl in
question is today a schoolteacher in Gujarat,
living out her life in obscurity.
Modi's father had apparently been afraid that his headstrong
son would become a sanyasin, and
hence sought to tempt him into a householder life. However, the strong-willed
Modi refused the conjugal bed and has since kept away from his would-be spouse,
by not meeting her even once after the "kanyadan”.
In an era when politicians live lives of luxury, the Gujarat CM stands out for
a sanyasin-like austerity
Because Modi has stopped the spoils system, in contrast to
Keshubhai Patel, under whom a culture of deal-making flourished, he is
unpopular with the many who see politics as the surest path towards enrichment.
Unlike in the past, these days, officers in Gujarat
--- whether in the police or in other branches of the administration --- work
without fear of punitive action by politicians angered by their refusal to
entertain suggestions for graft.
These days, the surest way to sudden tax-free wealth is to
be an anti-Modi BJP functionary, and the Congress Party is known to be generous
in its assistance to such elements. A check of the funding behind the numerous
anti-Modi rallies and gatherings would be instructive.
Over the past six months, a crescendo of criticism has been
heard about Narendra Modi, as much from within his Party as also from the
Congress, with the intention of causing his defeat in the forthcoming State Assembly
polls. Should the BJP return to power in Gujarat,
the credit for that will go to just one man, Narendra Modi.
Precisely what many within the top rungs of the BJP are
afraid of. These "second tier" leaders have prospered through
compromise and adjustment, with most having more friends in the Congress ranks
than within the BJP. They have come to hold high offices not because of
grass-roots work, but because of the patronage of the two patriarchs of the Saffron
Party, Vajpayee and Advani, and have spent almost all their time in "durbar" politics.
A Modi victory would represent a challenge from the grass-roots
to the coterie system that has been in control of the BJP almost since the Party's
inception, certainly since the mysterious death of Deen Dayal Upadhyaya.
With a third Assembly triumph in Gujarat
under his belt, Modi would emerge as the most popular and therefore most powerful
BJP leader, eclipsing Vajpayee. Over the past five years, he seems to have
moved away from religion-based politics into issues of development, embracing
both the English language as well as the MNCs in his push to make Gujarat a
state as affluent as California.
Should he win, hopefully he will make it a priority to reach
out to the minority communities, for only an inclusivist India can be a prospering India. Should
he win, the next official post that Modi may occupy is that of Prime Minister
of the Republic
of India. ---- INFA
(Copyright India News & Feature Alliance)
|