Open Forum
New
Delhi, 16 May 2019
Amid Polling & Counting
SUSPENSE PERIOD POLITICS
By Dr S. Saraswathi
(Former Director ICSSR, New Delhi)
Polling for 2019 Lok Sabha election, in seven phases
stretching to 39 days from April 11-May 19 has completed six phases. It is a
period of expectations for some parties and contestants and anxiety for all
without exception. While voters and non-voters patiently wait for the counting
day and political analysts and observers are busy calculating the chances of the
candidates, parties are preparing for post-poll alliances.
Seven weeks is a long period for polling and it
is certainly a tedious job policing the conduct of political parties and
candidates. The vigour of mutual attacks is growing from phase to phase. Several
agencies are conducting exit polls but cannot release the findings until all
phases of polling are completed.
Parties are making their own assessments of
polling trends and change their canvassing strategies and post-poll politics. In
the meantime, leaders have a common tendency of visualising their own victory
to draw voters in the last phase and prepare for post-counting operations.
2019 is witnessing by far the most bitter
election battle, which instead of subsiding after polling started intensified
further. Issues and promises are changing from place to place and along with
them the strategies of attacking one another.
The Election Commission is presently the most
sought after constitutional body to resolve the grievances of parties and
candidates. The Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) is the principal target of
attack of the current Opposition parties suspecting and voicing possibilities
of manipulation. It is partly preparatory to seeking refuge under the cover of
faulty machines in case of failure.
Nirvachan Sadan is flooded with complaints of
violations of Model Code of Conduct (MCC) never seen before. Derogatory and
provocative remarks and lies and distortions in campaign speeches have become common.
The EC in this election is cornered for both action
and inaction. Recall, on April 15, a Supreme Court bench headed by the CJI had pulled
it up for not acting against “hate speeches and statements on religious lines.”
After this, the EC took some action against top leaders of the Congress, the
BJP and even scrutinised PM’s speeches for violation of MCC. It also blocked
the release of the film “PM Narendra
Modi” during the election period.
Post-poll alliance is the hot topic among
many parties looking forward to a hung Parliament and a coalition government.
TDP leader Chandrababu Naidu, presently sticking to the theme of post-poll
alliance to keep the BJP out of power, forecasts only three possibilities -- grouping under Congress leadership; forming a
non-Congress, non-BJP grouping with “outside support of Congress” called Third
Front; or forming non-BJP alliance inclusive of the Congress. A meeting of Opposition
parties on completion of polling to exchange ideas on government formation, including
choice of PM is now postponed to take place after announcement of results.
To the TDP, the period between polling and
counting is a time for bringing together as many non-BJP parties as possible to
form and/or help to form a non-BJP government. For some parties, it will mean
reconciliation with a rival after a bitter election fight -- a move justified
as a “democratic and secular compulsion”. A front of non-Congress and non-BJP
parties, i.e. the Third Front of TRS does not appeal to TDP. Replacing Prime
Minister Modi is the principal objective of TDP leader.
TRS chief KCR, who was keen on a federal
front from the beginning of alliance talks in March last year and is hopeful of
winning all the 17 Lok Sabha seats in Telangana, has resumed the dialogue after
four phases of polling. Having opted for State Assembly election before the end
of its term and winning again with massive mandate, defeating both the Congress
and BJP, he is optimistic of a major role for regional parties in forming the
government at the Centre. In the hope of pushing both national parties – the
BJP and Congress – to be at the mercy of regional parties to build majority, he
has taken initiative to convert other regional parties to his line of thinking.
KCR has already met Kerala Chief Minister Vijayan,
had a telephonic conversation with Karnataka Chief Minister Kumaraswamy, and
has met DMK chief Stalin, also who does not support Third Front idea.
However, the desirability of re-enacting 1996
experiment in 2019 needs to be carefully examined by the potential allies. Politics
must be played for national interest and not for party or private benefits. Parties
are also readying excuses for bad performance and have picked on the EVM, which
is already at the centre of controversy with the Congress leading the Opposition
attack on lack of tamper-proof machines.
Recall, in February, the Opposition sought 50
per cent random verification of EVMs with Voter Verification Paper Audit Trial
(VVPAT) slips. The EC objected as this would extend the counting process and delay
the results.
In an unprecedented move, 21 non-NDA leaders
led by AP Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu moved the Supreme Court nearly a
month before the commencement of polling seeking a direction to the EC to count
VVPAT slips of at least 50% of EVMs in the General election, i.e. 125 polling
booths in every constituency. The signatories to the petition included leaders
from NCP, Congress, TMC, LJD, SP, BSP, DMK, CPM, CPI, RJD, AAP, NC, JDS, RLD,
AIUDF, HAM, JVM, IUML, NPF, and TJS. Though they have many differences amongst them
preventing pre-poll alliances, they are one in blaming the EVMs for their
losses in any place.
They challenged the EC’s guidelines which
make it mandatory for counting of VVPATs from only one random polling station
per Assembly constituency, which meant less than 0.44 per cent of EVMs in the
country. So on April 22, the Opposition
parties filed a review petition seeking at least “33% or 25%” VVPAT verification,
if not 50%. The review plea contended that “Indian democracy could not be left
to the mercy of EVM programmers”. It also complained of “large-scale tampering
and elective malfunctioning of EVMs in the Lok Sabha polls so far”.
The apex Court dismissed the plea to review
its judgement rejecting 50 per cent physical verification of EVMs using VVPATs.
The court directed the EC to increase physical counting of VVPAT slips to five
random EVMs in each Assembly segment/constituency.
Following the dismissal of the review
petition, a delegation of Opposition parties met the EC seeking “transparency”
in its functioning in order to ensure ‘free and fair’ election. It was also
explained that the review petition was filed “to underline a grave and serious
threat to democracy”. Affirming that they would abide by the Supreme Court’s
decision, the delegation expressed its intention of carrying on an all-India campaign
“to make the electorate and the citizens aware of the perils and pitfalls of
the current electoral process” thus choosing to lead the nation towards a
backward progress in the election system. Several complaints of malfunctioning
of the EVM-VVPAT machines are also being reported.
As the suspense period politics between
polling and counting is getting more and more murky, we have to shorten the
period since politics cannot be cleansed. ---INFA
(Copyright, India
News & Feature Alliance)
New
Delhi
14
May 2019
|